Calm Technology: What Belongs at the Centre of Your Screen, and What Belongs at the Edge

On a long drive you hear the engine the whole time, yet you never listen to it. Then it rattles, and in an instant it has all of you.

Illustration: A computer screen with one calm notification in the centre and quiet signals at the edges

In 1995 Mark Weiser and John Seely Brown at Xerox PARC proposed what they called calm technology: technology that informs but doesn't demand our focus or attention (Designing Calm Technology). Their example was a car engine. On a long drive you hear its hum the whole time, yet you never listen to it. Then one day it makes a new sound, a knock or a rattle, and in an instant it has all of you. Thirty years later, it is the best design brief for work notifications we have.

The centre and the edge

Offices have their own version. You can work beside a dozen conversations without hearing a word, until someone at the next desk says your name. Psychologists call it the cocktail party effect: the mind keeps listening at the edges and lets through only what concerns you.

That is the ideal for a notification: present at the edge, and in the centre only when something has changed that needs you. Mapped onto the types of notifications, the picture is simple:

  • At the edge: informational updates, presence dots, typing indicators, likes and reactions. Seen without being looked at.
  • In a place you visit on purpose: action-required items like approvals and reviews.
  • Briefly through the centre: awareness alerts, urgent news that asks nothing of you.
  • In the centre until you act: only the time-sensitive and the true emergency.
Most overload comes from notifications that are peripheral in value but central in delivery.
Game · 7 notifications

Centre or edge?

Where should each notification live in a calm system? Sort them and see how close your instincts are to calm technology.

This interactive part needs JavaScript.

Free ebookThe Language of InterruptionThe research behind every notification you get at work: where they came from, what they cost and what to do about them. 131 pages, free PDF.Get it free →

Why everything ends up in the centre

Because the centre is the default. Most apps deliver every event as a banner, with a sound and a badge, unless someone changes it. And because every app competes to be the one you return to, the loudest delivery is the safest bet for the app, if not for you. The result is a screen where a like and an outage arrive in the same rectangle, with the same sound.

Research backs up the cost. In a study of 10,372 notifications received by 20 people, even notifications with important or useful content could still be disruptive (Mehrotra et al., CHI 2016). Useful is not the same as worth interrupting for.

How to make your notifications calmer

  1. Move status to the edge. Turn off banners for presence, typing and reactions. Let them live as dots and counts you see when you look.
  2. Give action items a home. A to-do list, a pinned channel or a saved-for-later list you visit on purpose.
  3. Reserve the centre. Use Focus or Do Not Disturb so that only named people and genuinely urgent alerts break through. Our guide on when to mute shows how.
  4. Let silence mean something. In a calm system, the absence of a notification says: everything is on track.

Frequently asked questions

What is calm technology?

A design idea from Mark Weiser and John Seely Brown at Xerox PARC in 1995: technology should inform without demanding attention, staying at the periphery until something changes that needs you.

How does calm technology apply to notifications?

Ambient status and updates should live at the edge of the screen, action items in a place you visit on purpose, and only time-sensitive alerts and emergencies should interrupt.

What is the cocktail party effect?

The ability to tune out surrounding conversations while still noticing when someone says your name, a model for how notifications should work.

Sources

  1. Weiser and Brown, Designing Calm Technology (1995)
  2. Cocktail party effect, Wikipedia
  3. Mehrotra et al., My phone and me: understanding people's receptivity to mobile notifications, CHI 2016

The hum was always there. It only moved to the centre when something changed.

MMWritten byMarina MaksimovicFounder of Noticue and author of The Language of Interruption. She writes about how work notifications shape our attention, and builds the app that digests them.
One inbox for Slack, Gmail, Outlook and Asana.Noticue reads every notification, tells you what is urgent and plans your day. Free for the first 200 members.Get early access
Free for the first 200 members

Your unified notification inbox for Slack, Gmail, Outlook and Asana.

Every alert understood, prioritised, and ready to act on. We don’t manage your work. We digest it for you.

No credit card needed