People, Systems, AI: Why Who Is Speaking Changes the Message

A notification is also a voice, and the same words sound different depending on who says them.

Illustration: Three message bubbles from a person, a system gear and an AI sparkle

"Can you look at this today?" From your manager, it is a priority. From a ticketing tool, it is one of forty. From an AI assistant, it is a guess you might want to check. One sentence, three different requests. Who is speaking is the third dimension of every notification, alongside what it asks and how soon, and it can move a message from "now" to "never" in an instant.

The three voices of work notifications

  1. People carry intent. A colleague asks, tells or thanks, and we read the words through the person: their role, their habits, and how often their "urgent" has been real.
  2. Systems carry facts. Tools report every event precisely and never tire, so they speak most often. That volume teaches people to tune them out.
  3. AI agents carry interpretations. The newest voice speaks mostly about other notifications: a summary, a digest, a note that something needs you. How much weight it gets depends on how often it has been right.
Free ebookThe Language of InterruptionThe research behind every notification you get at work: where they came from, what they cost and what to do about them. 131 pages, free PDF.Get it free →

What hospitals learned about machine voices

The clearest evidence of what happens when systems speak too often comes from hospitals, where the voice is a machine and the stakes are high. Studies there report that 72% to 99% of clinical alarms may be false, and staff grow less sensitive to all of them, the real ones included. Hospitals call it alarm fatigue (Europe PMC). Work tools are not ICUs, but the same slope applies: when a tool cries wolf all day, the one real alert sounds like the rest.

A notification is not a point on a map. It is a point in a box: what it asks, how soon, and who is asking.
Game · 6 notifications

How would you treat it, depending on who sent it?

The same kind of message from different voices. Decide what each deserves.

This interactive part needs JavaScript.

The AI voice: trust that has to be earned

AI is the voice most likely to speak in someone else's place. When Microsoft ran an AI-written daily briefing email listing the promises people had made in their own emails, users valued the reminders, but the most common complaints were inaccurate or out-of-date items and reminders for tasks already done (Microsoft Research). One frequent user even changed how they wrote emails so the briefing would catch their action items. The reader had begun to write for the machine.

How to weigh each voice

  • People: calibrate to the person. If someone's "urgent" is usually real, let them through your Focus mode. If it rarely is, ask them for deadlines (see fake urgency at work).
  • Systems: keep only the alerts that need a person to act, and route the rest into a digest. Fewer machine alerts means the real ones get heard.
  • AI: treat summaries as an index, keep the original a tap away, and spot-check regularly (see Your AI Chief of Staff).

Frequently asked questions

What is alarm fatigue?

When people are exposed to so many alarms, most of them false or unimportant, that they become less responsive to all alarms, including real ones. It is well documented in hospitals.

Should I trust AI notifications?

Trust them as much as they have earned. Treat summaries and reminders as a guide, keep the original a tap away, and spot-check them regularly.

Why do I ignore system notifications?

Because systems report every event without judgement, so most of their alerts do not need you. Keep only the ones that need a person to act.

Sources

  1. Alarm fatigue: a patient safety concern, Europe PMC
  2. Morrison, Iqbal and Horvitz, AI-powered reminders for collaborative tasks, Microsoft Research (CSCW 2024)

Three things decide how a notification lands: what it asks, how soon, and who is asking.

MMWritten byMarina MaksimovicFounder of Noticue and author of The Language of Interruption. She writes about how work notifications shape our attention, and builds the app that digests them.
One inbox for Slack, Gmail, Outlook and Asana.Noticue reads every notification, tells you what is urgent and plans your day. Free for the first 200 members.Get early access
Free for the first 200 members

Your unified notification inbox for Slack, Gmail, Outlook and Asana.

Every alert understood, prioritised, and ready to act on. We don’t manage your work. We digest it for you.

No credit card needed